Literary masterpiece

This is an ambitious undertaking by Shashi Tharoor where he attempts a retelling of the Mahabharata while simultaneously entwining the narrative threads from the epic to Indian history in the 20th century. It is a must-read for every Indian and Tharoor's witty and masterful prose makes it perfectly suitable for the audiobook format as well.

To point this out at the outset, I would rate the audio performance as just OK. The narrator is drab at certain points and (probably as the result of the 'neutral' accent he puts on) trips at certain Indian names and 'Indianisms'. I wouldn't say this is too big a deal though because the performance is largely serviceable and doesn't break immersion for the most part. Still, one wishes that Tharoor would have narrated the book himself which would have made it all the more enjoyable.

To come to the story, I do not exaggerate when I say that I loved every word of it. The writing style is very reminiscent of Rushdie's brand of magical realism to which the book pays explicit homage. But Tharoor's use of the Indian political landscape as a means to bring fantastical stories from the epics into contemporary reality grounds the book in a way that amazes the reader at every turn.

The first half of the book, which is set in pre-Independence India and centers on the characters of Bhishma (Gandhi), Pandu (Bose), Dhritarashtra (Nehru), Karna (Jinnah), and others, makes for an enjoyable listen. Tharoor uses word-play, allusions, and ingenious narrative devices to bridge Mahabharata characters and events with their chosen historical counterpart and does justice to both stories in the process. There are references to Puranic stories, books, and historical personages littered throughout the narrative, and finding them serves as a delectable Easter egg hunt. The setting of the Raj also allows for the author to throw light on his criticisms of British rule that he has expounded upon in his later books and speeches. Representatives of the colonial rule are brought down to size and depicted as if in a farce to highlight the ridiculousness of it all.

The second half of the book switches gear and as it meanders from the birth of Indian democracy to Emergency (the wounds of which would have still been fresh at the time of the book's publishing) and its aftermath, this is where the book really shines. The author distills the essence of the epic, its morally grey characters, and complex themes into political philosophy and gives a lot of food for thought.

Talking about political commentary, Tharoor (but not his stand-in narrator in the novel) tries to remain politically agnostic for the most part by which I mean that he does not balk at the prospect of causing offense to representatives of every hue of the Indian political spectrum. This is especially true in the depiction of Mrs. Indira Gandhi, cast as Duryodhana, the big-bad of the Mahabharata. But her opponents are not white-washed either.
It would be very interesting to see a sequel dealing with more modern history in the same style that takes no prisoners. One also wonders how he would have cast the present actors on the political scene. Especially considering that he now numbers among them and had a front-row seat for half of the political drama over the last few decades and was on the stage for the rest.
That said, I will not pretend that such a book would see the light of day in the current political climate. There would certainly be clarion calls for censorship and cancellation (and not just from the ruling dispensation).
Of course, that makes this book all the more precious.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Great Indian Novel Indeed!

The parallels between contemporary Indian history and the Mahabharata were spot on. Enjoyed it thoroughly.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Could be more respectable towards freedom fighters

While the book is good and enjoyable, the narrative could be more respectable towards freedom fighters like Nehru and Bose. Only their drawbacks and faults are mentioned. Their virtues and good deeds are totally ignored. The same author wrote another book praising Nehru after joining Congress. Even best of the people change colors and stripes in politics.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Terribly Read

Being a big fan of Audible, I was sorely disappointed by the quality of the reading. Poor pronunciation fought with false "plumminess" reminding one of educated poorly educated primary school teacher who tries but fails to mimic "BBC-speak". The inability to separate the different people in a running conversation made hearing the book a chore, and I've finally given up. Pl don't let this vocal poseur near a recording studio.
Let Tharoor read his own stuff

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Understanding of Mahabharata

This book is a great inspiration for youngsters to know about Indian great epic and philosophical . This is real Ayr fantasy belief is a big question to me . Even in a book a times give impression that story is imaginary,overall enhance knowledge and world wise importance of our heritage. We must know to define our country USP.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Vivid imagination Excellent Prose

very humorous and thought provoking, all at the same time. i doubt if this novel could have been published in today's climate of hyper sensitivity

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

great comparative between Mahabharat

good novel. fun interpretation between politics and mythology. the characters are well developed and interesting

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

How Shashi Tharoor drew the analogy between Mahabharata and Indian Politics when the independence movement started

I loved the narration of the book. it was engaging. Learned some more things about Maharashtra and got a perspective of various events during and after the freedom struggle

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

No book has made me as furious as this one !

I really don't know how can this book been reviewed and recommended so highly. this was my first Tharoor book, and an awful one at that. I can't even say one good thing about this - the narration was awful robotic, creativity originality ? nope. a blatant subjective opinion of a congress apologist who utterly degrades both our history as well as our epic.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!